Muncie Community Schools Teacher Contract Appeal Denied

Teachers at Muncie Community Schools will now work under a contract created by the Muncie Teachers Association.  That’s after a state board declined an appeal by the school district Tuesday at a meeting in Indianapolis.  As IPR’s Tony Sandleben reports, the nearly year-long battle was an effort to balance the budget at the financially-strained district.

A unanimous decision by the Indiana Education Employment Relations Board, or IEERB, ended any hope of Muncie teachers working under the school board’s version of a new teachers contract. IEERB voted to uphold the state fact finder’s decision, meaning the teachers will work under a contract written by the Muncie Teachers Association. MTA President Pat Kennedy had a message for teachers.

“Feel good about this decision. IEERB does not come down on the side of teachers very often, and we were right. That’s what I want them to remember.”

MCS Superintendent Steven Baule was not as enthusiastic, saying this means more difficult decisions will have to be made.

“It probably means we’re going to make many deeper cuts. It’s that simple. I mean, there is no money. Nobody’s arguing that. Basically, one of the issues is we multiple years of mismanagement that we’re trying to catch up on.”

Tuesday’s decision means teachers will not receive a pay raise for the two years the contract will cover, and there will be an increase in insurance premiums. However, Kennedy says the increase in money coming out of teachers’ paychecks is acceptable to teachers, but the appeal process itself may have already caused unnecessary damage.

“Had this decision been made or had the appeal not been filed, we wouldn’t be losing so many teachers as we are. They had to move on.”

By Kennedy’s count, 75 teachers have left MCS since the 2016-2017 school year began. While Tuesday’s decision was not what Superintendent Baule was hoping for, he did say that it was no reason for the public to panic.

“I don’t think there’s a need for immediate concern. We’re still going to continue to offer the best school we possibly can afford.

Baule went on to say this decision would not affect any plans of building a new middle school as funding for that project is tied to a referendum. The school board tabled a discussion about a referendum at a previous meeting.