The Clark County Democratic Party plans to challenge two tight races in Southern Indiana, including one where Republican incumbent Chris Garten won reelection to Indiana Senate District 45 by a few hundred votes.
The party issued a news release Thursday saying it intends to file for recount and challenge for the Senate and Clark County Auditor’s races. The first possible day to do so is Friday.
The move comes days after the Clark County Election Board voted 2-1 not to manually count ballots from a polling place that saw technical issues on Election Day. Board members said at the Tuesday meeting they had conflicting information on whether they could legally do that, and one said there was no ballot shortfall.
“The election board could have cleared this up with one simple step: count the ballots and confirm they match the number of voters. The board refused,” Clark County Democratic Party Chair Miguel Hampton said in the release. “Now we’re facing an expensive, drawn-out process that didn’t need to happen.”
Unofficial results showed Garten winning reelection over Democratic challenger Nick Marshall by fewer than 300 votes for Indiana Senate District 45. In Clark County, the largest area the seat represents, Garten won by 447 votes. In Floyd, a much smaller portion of the district, Marshall got 150 more votes.
For the Clark County Auditor’s race, Democrat Antonio Veals lost to Republican Monty Snelling by 257 votes.
Election Day issues at Jeffersonville High School — including a machine that had to be replaced, a late timestamp on the ballot tape after it was switched and ballots held in an auxiliary bin in the meantime — led some people to question the accuracy of those results.
Debate over discrepancies
Hampton, the Clark County Democratic Party chair, said on Monday the county has a history of inconsistencies that can flip results, and that “it could overturn both those races if you find out that there is enough discrepancy.”
The Clark County Election Board met Tuesday to vote on whether to manually count the ballots cast at four precincts at Jeffersonville High School. Democratic board Chair Andy Steele said he hoped doing so would help ease doubts, but the three-member board ultimately voted 2-1 against counting.
Republican board member Tony Singleton said in a resolution the board had determined the main concern about voter turnout and ballot totals was “based upon an assumption that turnout in the affected precincts was substantially lower than expected.”
But he said that, after reviewing information including election returns and absentee voting records, that did not bear out.
He said the board found “no evidence that any ballot cast was not tabulated, that voting equipment failed to record ballots cast, or that examination of sealed ballot containers is necessary to resolve the concerns presented to the board.”
In a statement this week, Garten called the ballot count concerns “political theater,” noting his team’s review of pollbooks found slightly more ballots than the number of voters recorded, which wasn’t enough to change the race’s outcome.
Indiana Democratic Party Chair Karen Tallian and 9th District Democratic Party Chair Adam Dickey said in a Tuesday statement that “the whole country should pay attention to what’s going on in Clark County.”
They pointed to mechanical failures, electronic pollbook discrepancies and “critical staffing issues,” and said the board should have verified all votes had been counted.
“We must continue to push for transparency, honesty, and to ensure that every legal vote is counted,” they said, according to the statement. “We will pursue all available legal avenues, including a recount and/or contest of the results in Senate District 45 and Clark County.”
Indiana Republican Party Chair Lana Keesling also called for national attention to Clark County in a statement this week.
“The people of Senate District 45 sent a clear message on Election Day. Now Democrats are launching a baseless fishing expedition in an attempt to overturn the results of an election they lost,” she said.
Keesling said the party has confidence in the state’s election officials and the election process.
“There is no evidence of missing votes and no reason to believe the outcome will change,” she said.
Could they count?
Questions around the close races come as Democrats brought in big wins locally, statewide and nationally, with Beau Bayh winning Indiana secretary of state, voters breaking the Republican supermajority at the Statehouse and local Democratic candidates unseating some Republican incumbents in Clark and Floyd counties.
Sellersburg resident Nancy McDevitt said at the Tuesday meeting she has worked local elections and wanted the board to count ballots.
“We have Democrats and Republicans working together. We have rules, and everybody’s very helpful,” she said. “I trust our system, and the reason I suggest to you that we check this farther, is because we want to continue to trust our system.”
Lynch, the county clerk, said at Tuesday’s meeting that board members received “conflicting interpretations” from the Indiana Election Division on their authority to physically count ballots after Election Day and that he didn’t think they should proceed without clear guidance.
“I absolutely support ensuring the accuracy and integrity of our elections, and I believe legitimate concerns deserve appropriate review,” he said, adding that “I personally do not believe that the information currently…presented at that time establishes a sufficient statistical or legal basis to proceed with a ballot count.”
Lynch said after the meeting he didn’t want to risk breaking the law, and that he respected the process and candidates’ rights to a recount.
“Since we did get polar opposite responses, guidance, I would err on the side of caution of not acting and allowing the law to play out however the concerned parties choose,” he said.
Steele said the hand count may have been the “easiest way to make people go, ‘Oh, OK. Well, there’s nothing wrong here, nothing to see.’ My cohorts didn’t see it that way, so we’ll just move along.”
Ted Nolting, who was at the meeting on behalf of Garten, said he admired the board’s desire to provide information to the public. But he advised that the board didn’t have the authority to open and count ballots. He said there were actually 28 more ballots cast than voters listed, “so there are no missing ballots.” He added that bipartisan pollworkers watched the process.
“You had Democrat and Republican poll workers there watching, taking pictures,” Nolting said. “You had people verifying the vote counts. So, again, from our perspective, it’s much ado about nothing.”
Attorney Mickey Weber is representing Marshall, Veals and the local Democratic Party.
“The board’s resolution said its members had carefully examined the issues. At the meeting, however, it became clear they had reviewed the information only through a screenshot,” Weber said, according to the news release. “The resolution misstates what they’ve actually done.”
At Tuesday’s meeting, Weber said the parties were considering a recount or election contest, and that “the votes cast at Jeffersonville High School “exceed the margin of victory for these two races.”
“That alone, if they’re not counted, would be enough to cast doubt on the results of the election. So we’re going to be exploring our options,” he said.
The Indiana Senate Majority Caucus recently selected Garten to serve as Senate President Pro Tem, after Republican Rodric Bray said he wouldn’t seek a new term in the position. The Democratic caucus will also weigh in on Garten’s position during the legislature’s Organization Day, Nov. 17.
Friday, Nov. 13 is the first day candidates or parties can file a verified recount or contest petition. Candidates have until noon on Tuesday, Nov. 17 to file, and parties have until Nov. 20.