Pendleton and Fall Creek Township residents critical of proposed reorganization

By Thomas Ouellette, IPR News | Published on in Community, Government, Local News, Politics
A historic map of Fall Creek Township in Madison County, Indiana.
Fall Creek Township is one of several in Madison County. (Map: The Madison County Cemetery Commission)

Residents of Fall Creek Township and Pendleton were critical of a citizen-led reorganization that would combine the two entities on their terms.  As IPR’s Thomas Ouellette reports, the process was begun at a meeting this week as a way to protect the township from a forced merger through a state law.

  • Audio Transcript

    A state law governing the future fate of all townships says if townships like Fall Creek receive a failing grade on a state-created rubric in December, it could be forced to merge with a different town or township without any negotiation.

    Read More from 2023: Report provides recommendations for more efficient townships throughout the state

    The citizen-led reorganization would see Fall Creek become part of Pendleton while still retaining things like its own rural codes and tax rates.

    Senator Mike Gaskill was one of the attendees who voiced opposition to the citizen-led effort.

    “There would be two sets of rules. Can you imagine selecting a town council that had two sets of rules?” he said. “One for the rural residents and one for the town residents. If we’re gonna be together, we can’t have that.”

    Resident Cole Buttry said the reorganization is a way to ensure control over Fall Creek stays local.

    “If we don’t allow the planning work to proceed. We will be at the mercy of the Madison County planners,” said Buttry. “They will make decisions about our area from long distance with more regard for the county financials than for the protection of our local farms and residents.”

    The public hearing was recessed and will continue for a second day on December 3.  Once the hearing concludes, the Fall Creek Township board will have 30 days to take a vote on continuing the reorganization.

    According to the Department of Local Government Finance, there are six steps that a reorganization must go through before a vote takes place:

    • A petition brings the proposal to the township board.
    • The board then considers the proposal and chooses to move forward or not.
    • The Town of Pendleton will respond and announce whether or not it will participate in the reorganization.
    • If both Pendleton and Fall Creek Township agree to participate, they must prepare a written plan.
    • Pendleton and Fall Creek Township will hold separate hearings on that written plan.
    • Resident of both Pendleton and Fall Creek Township vote in favor or against the reorganization.

    A township is considered as “failing” with a state-created score sheet with 10 different criteria.  Included is measuring how large or small a township’s budget is and knowing if it actively manages fire protection or emergency medical services.  Points are awarded for smaller budgets, smaller responsibilities, and fewer assistance to the community. If a township scores four or more points, it is designated for a merger.

    The Department of Local Government Finance will evaluate every township in Indiana by December 31, 2026.

    Thomas Ouellette is our reporter and producer. Contact him at thomas.ouellette@bsu.edu.

    NOW PLAYING

    Indiana Public Radio

    Live on 92.1 FM Muncie | 90.9 FM Marion | 91.1 FM Hagerstown / New Castle

    From IPR