Audio Transcript
Please note: Accuracy and availability of IPR transcripts may vary.
00;00;00;04 - 00;00;19;23
Sean Ashcraft
Ashcraft: Support for the facing project comes from Behavior Associates providing intensive therapy, individualized academic instruction, and social skills training for children with autism behavior associates analysts develop an individualized treatment plan for each child receiving services. Presenting sponsor of the facing project. More at behavior ABA.
00;00;19;25 - 00;00;48;28
J.R. Jamison
Jamison: I'm J.R. Jamison today on the Facing project, I'll explore empathy. It's the basis of our work here at the Facing Project, and humans are hard wired for it through mirror neurons. But time, culture and climate determine if empathy grows, remains neutral, or worse, leads to anger or apathy. I'll share the stories of two women, one who teaches kids empathy through drama therapy, and the other who found it by loving her trans daughter.
00;00;49;04 - 00;01;13;16
J.R. Jamison
Later, former co-host Kelsey Timmerman joins me for a two way where we unpack all of this and make the argument for why empathy, if practiced in the right ways, has the ability to save us all. Stay with us for the empathy effect.
00;01;13;18 - 00;01;34;03
J.R. Jamison
Jamison: I can still remember the moment when I knew the facing project had the ability to shape hearts and minds, which, by the way, was not even the facing project at the time. This was back in 2012, and my good friend and fellow writer, Kelsey Timmerman reached out to me about a project he was working on called Facing Poverty in Delaware County, Indiana.
00;01;34;06 - 00;01;58;02
J.R. Jamison
Much like the current model of the facing project, storytellers and writers were partnered together to collaborate on first person narratives told from the storytellers perspectives. I was partnered with a woman named Pat, and I knew nothing about her before we met, other than she was associated with poverty in Delaware County in some way. What happened next changed the course of my and Kelsey's work.
00;01;58;04 - 00;02;30;18
J.R. Jamison
Pat and I met on a sunny winter morning at an I hop and took a corner booth. I had a series of questions mapped out before me, my recorder rolling, and before I could even ask the first question, Pat said, could we just have a conversation? And with that simple request, the script was flipped. Since I had my recorder as a backup, I agreed, and Pat and I spent three hours talking about love and loss, hope and heartbreak, and I shared as much of my story as she shared of hers.
00;02;30;25 - 00;02;53;12
J.R. Jamison
Through our conversation, we found our similarities and our differences, but more than anything, it helped us build rapport and empathy. That first meeting was only the start of a series of meetings Pat and I would have over the course of the following weeks as we crafted her story, and in the months in the years that followed as we remained in touch.
00;02;53;14 - 00;03;37;03
J.R. Jamison
I was so moved by this connection and responsibility of carrying someone else's story that I said to Kelsey, I thought we had something more, and that something more became the facing project. 11 years later, we have used the model to help over 100 communities in 18 US states in 11 countries tell their stories in the same way. Time and again, we've continued to hear this storytelling, heightened empathy and understanding, and of course, changed hearts, minds and inspired action such as LGBTQ plus individuals becoming a protected class in a small Ohio town and food pantries opening on college campuses for food insecure students and staff.
00;03;37;05 - 00;04;05;03
J.R. Jamison
That's the power of a personal narrative, but we needed to know for sure. So in 2016, we embarked on a three year longitudinal study on attitude change. The surveyed over 7500 past participants of facing projects. I won't bore you with all the stats, but we did find that 91% indicated our model challenged previously held stereotypes, and 100% found it easier to understand the perspective of others.
00;04;05;04 - 00;04;31;08
J.R. Jamison
That's a win, right? Well, we think so, but over the past few years, it's felt like empathy is slowly decreasing within communities. Indeed, studies from the National Institute of Health are showing a rapid decline in empathy among youth due to high levels of distress, which makes sense given that we've experienced three years of a global pandemic among a whole host of other issues, such as increasing poverty and hunger.
00;04;31;11 - 00;04;57;26
J.R. Jamison
And among adults, we're seeing a decline in empathy due to tribalism and cultural wars. So do stories still have the ability to heighten empathy and understanding? Well stay tuned. Today, you'll hear from a theater director who opened the imagination of kids in her community with a guitar and some creative thinking. And from a mom of a trans daughter who ask others to have a change of heart.
00;04;58;02 - 00;05;15;12
J.R. Jamison
Later, Kelsey rejoins me to unpack all of this, and we make the argument for why empathy, if practiced in the right ways, has the ability to save us all. Due to some strong language and content that may be disturbing to some. Listener discretion is advised.
00;05;15;14 - 00;05;40;14
Lorri Markum
Markum: The world through the eyes of another. Laura Williamson's story as told to Monique Armstrong and performed by Lorri Markum. I can stand with those who are walking through deep waters because I've walked through my own. My three year old son died unexpectedly. Doesn't get much deeper than that. Tragedy can find us, but it's our response that determines whether we thrive beyond mere existence.
00;05;40;20 - 00;06;07;15
Lorri Markum
I've lived a miracle and experienced crippling loss, but through it all, the response that I chose during the most difficult days is belief in something. And I believe in the power of drama therapy. I had the privilege to interpret the role of Hello Dolly's main character, Dolly Levi, at the Muncie Civic Theater. The last time I had played Dolly, I was in high school, and there was a big difference playing Dolly at 40 versus 16.
00;06;07;17 - 00;06;31;29
Lorri Markum
I had lived a lot more life. I knew love, unimaginable loss and been through a really dark time. I hadn't acted in seven years when I took that role, but I was ready. There are three scenes in the play where Dolly's on stage alone, speaking directly to her deceased husband. She talks about being ready to rejoin humanity. She wanted to get back to life.
00;06;32;01 - 00;07;07;21
Lorri Markum
I'm ready to move out in front. Life without life has no reason or rhyme left with the rest of them. With the best of them. I want to hold my head up high. I need a goal again. I need a drive again. I want to feel my heart coming alive again. Before the parade passes by.
00;07;07;23 - 00;07;29;11
Lorri Markum
With each performance in rehearsal. When Dolly committed to live again, I did the same thing. This allowed me to tap into feelings for eight shows in a way that traditional therapy just couldn't. When we see the world through the eyes and emotions of another, we see the hope in their story, the possibility of it all. I wanted to bring that feeling to the students that motivate our minds.
00;07;29;12 - 00;07;53;03
Lorri Markum
They run an after school program that helps kids with homework, and connects them to people and opportunities that they may not normally be exposed to, and they were all in. So I showed up on a Friday with a box of scarves and my guitar. The students, all pre-teens, came up with the details of our play, the characters, how they were related to one another, the names and the backstories.
00;07;53;04 - 00;08;16;25
Lorri Markum
It was sort of an ongoing soap opera, not meant to be a performance, really. It was more about the process. Any big decisions in our play? They voted on, but I was surprised by the setting they chose. And affluent middle class junior high in Southern California. Can't get much further from Muncie, Indiana than that. There was another layer to the play at this school in Southern California.
00;08;16;26 - 00;08;36;13
Lorri Markum
There was a portal that, once the students stepped through it, transported them to another realm where they would have superpowers. They always enjoyed the superpowers the most. I was always the most interested in the conflicts that they would choose to face. They'd get hung up on the idea that someone was being accused of something they didn't do, or a teacher was playing favorites.
00;08;36;14 - 00;08;57;05
Lorri Markum
It was always about fairness in grade school justice, things they were likely to try to make sense of in their own everyday lives. I started to mentor one of the boys who had aged out of the program. He was really talented. He could pursue theater as a career if he wanted, and I encouraged him to get involved at the civic, and he's been a staple there ever since.
00;08;57;10 - 00;09;15;25
Lorri Markum
I think the theater has surrounded him with a community who has accepted him. One of the other students didn't trust me. She lived with her grandfather and she was tough, very tough, and it seemed like life was a struggle for her. She kind of had the attitude like, this is stupid, but since I'm here, I might as well participate.
00;09;15;27 - 00;09;39;05
Lorri Markum
She had a big personality and could sway the group, but I noticed she had an eye for directing. So as I was putting together the performance for mom's annual event, I asked her if she'd help. She loved it. Now she's very involved with the Muncie Civic Theater and she works on the kids shows. I watch her wearing a headset, pulling the curtain up to reveal the stage that the boy I mentor dances and sings on the same stage.
00;09;39;05 - 00;09;56;00
Lorri Markum
I played Dolly on the same stage, where pretending to be someone else encouraged me to live again.
00;09;56;02 - 00;10;20;07
Laura Williamson
Williamson: Hearts and homes. Katie Flesch’s story as told to Kate DeVantier, performed by Laura Williamson. I've taken great care in constructing my home, not the physical house. There's like a 1 in 5 chance every day that I'll fall in the parking lot. Walking in heels to work each morning so I stay away from hammers and nails when possible. No, I mean home.
00;10;20;10 - 00;10;46;20
Laura Williamson
Not just a material structure, but a feeling of love and acceptance. It's not always an easy thing to construct, but because of my daughter Elizabeth, I found the most amazing community in which to do so. I've learned a lot of things from Elizabeth. Even at seven years old, with dark, springy curls and a toothy grin. She knows herself better than most 40 year old women I know.
00;10;46;22 - 00;11;15;04
Laura Williamson
He's so self-aware. Elizabeth is honestly one of the most amazing children I've ever encountered. She's beautiful and smart and funny and talented. She also happens to have been born a boy ever since. She was able to communicate and have her own personality. I knew there was something different about her. For me, it was a matter of putting the puzzle pieces together and figuring out what it was.
00;11;15;05 - 00;11;42;18
Laura Williamson
But despite all the possible scenarios, transgender never crossed my mind. For a lot of people, that might have been a stumbling block. Luckily, because I'm pretty open minded, I never had a second thought about it. It took a little time, but for me, there's no question you just love your kid. We've been transitioning for a few months now.
00;11;42;24 - 00;12;11;27
Laura Williamson
You can see a difference. Elizabeth is really living and authentic life, and she's happy. She started to build a strong foundation for her future home, her own space of love and acceptance. While her transition has been pretty smooth so far, we haven't been without our own cracks in the walls. I've had people state that I have a mental condition, and that my children should be taken away by child Protective Services.
00;12;12;00 - 00;12;39;07
Laura Williamson
It's like there's this gang mentality. People have this preconceived notion about transgender people. They're not real or it's disease or a mental illness or parents create the situation. They think, I took a little boy and put him in a dress. Please. I can't even get my kids to eat broccoli. Elizabeth experiences it, too. One little girl told her that Jesus doesn't approve of that.
00;12;39;07 - 00;13;10;29
Laura Williamson
That's not what Jesus wants. Pretty heavy stuff to deal with. She's very sensitive and very loving and compassionate. She wants everyone to like her and be happy. When someone says something hurtful, something she sits and thinks about, it sticks. It's hard to build with crumbling blocks, but this experience has also given us tools. What I've found is I have amazing support for the most part.
00;13;11;01 - 00;13;37;12
Laura Williamson
We have had the most loving and positive reception as a whole. The LGBTQ community is so much more accepting and loving than many of us, and I am so honored that they have accepted me as a part of their family. I don't think the LGBTQ community is as small as everyone thinks. I feel like there are other children out there.
00;13;37;15 - 00;14;03;13
Laura Williamson
Their parents are afraid to come forward or the children are afraid to come forward. I just hope that by being so open and telling our story, it'll show families that it's okay to let your child be who they are. There is a support system locally. We can be your home. This community I am a part of is a family of welders, not wrecking balls.
00;14;03;16 - 00;14;30;04
Laura Williamson
We bring things together. We make them stronger. You can't be a weak person or a weak parent and be out like we are. We can be hit with a lot of negativity, but this whole experience has taught me to be more loving and accepting. I see this as an opportunity for me to advocate and educate and maybe create a path for a better future for Elizabeth.
00;14;30;07 - 00;14;59;00
Laura Williamson
It really just boils down to loving your child for exactly who they are. Here's the thing. The whole situation going on in the country right now, with all the turmoil and all the hate. It's not really an issue about God, or about lifestyle choices or about sin or hell. It's an issue about heart and acceptance. People need to live in their own houses, and if they don't want to visit their neighbor's house, they don't.
00;14;59;03 - 00;15;29;27
Laura Williamson
They especially don't need to vandalize or destroy it. I wouldn't change Elizabeth for anything. This is a girl, after learning about adoption, cried because there are babies in the world with no parents. This is a girl who spends her time tearing napkins into paper hearts to give to people she just met. This is a girl who hopes that all people transgender are not can have a happy life.
00;15;30;00 - 00;15;56;04
Laura Williamson
Some people might take issue with the first four words of the preceding sentences. As her mother, I am most proud of what comes after. A lot of people have reached out and called her a hero for being brave enough to speak her story, but she doesn't know any different. That's just Elizabeth, and it's been an adventure and just a joy to see her bloom into who she is.
00;15;56;06 - 00;16;32;29
Laura Williamson
I am so blessed to have the community that I do. I am a part of a family of acceptance, kindness, compassion, understanding, and love. These are the elemental stones with which we build our house. If you're ever in the neighborhood, just knock on our door. We are always home.
00;16;33;01 - 00;16;52;21
Sean Ashcraft
Ashcraft: Support for the facing project comes from Behavior Associates providing intensive therapy, individualized academic instruction, and social skills training for children with autism. Behavior associates analysts develop an individualized treatment plan for each child receiving services. Presenting sponsor of the facing project. More at behavior ABA.
00;16;52;23 - 00;17;08;23
J.R. Jamison
Jamison: I want to welcome back to the show Kelsey Timmerman, former co-host on The Facing Project radio show, my Co-Founder on the Facing Project, My Friend. New York Times bestselling author. Keep going. You've been busy.
00;17;08;25 - 00;17;10;04
Kelsey Timmerman
Timmerman: I have been.
00;17;10;05 - 00;17;11;26
J.R. Jamison
Jamison: So what have you been up to?
00;17;11;27 - 00;17;27;13
Kelsey Timmerman
Timmerman: Well, I decided it would be a good idea to go back to grad school and become a better storyteller and help other people become better storytellers. At the same time, while I'm researching and writing and traveling for my fourth book. So it kind of became a little bit overwhelming.
00;17;27;13 - 00;17;37;06
Kelsey Timmerman
So I just kind of like disappeared a little bit from the show. There's no, like, dramatic Behind the Music episode of. Yeah, where there was a split.
00;17;37;07 - 00;17;39;26
J.R. Jamison
Jamison: There was some split between us or something. No.
00;17;39;29 - 00;17;41;12
Kelsey Timmerman
Timmerman: Yeah, that's not that.
00;17;41;14 - 00;17;44;09
J.R. Jamison
Jamison: Yeah. So did you become a better storyteller?
00;17;44;10 - 00;18;03;20
Kelsey Timmerman
Timmerman: I hope so. So I'm, like, working on the edits in my book right now and should come out in 2024. And I got the degree. I got a chance to teach students writing, which was great. And now I'm actually teaching some classes here at Ball State, which is fun.
00;18;03;21 - 00;18;10;18
J.R. Jamison
Jamison: That's awesome. It could I audit one of those courses? If I wanted to become a better story, I would charge you extra.
00;18;10;20 - 00;18;12;09
Kelsey Timmerman
Timmerman: Okay, I won't charge you extra.
00;18;12;10 - 00;18;37;24
J.R. Jamison
Jamison: Well, speaking of storytelling, I opened this episode talking about when we first started the Facing project, and, well, actually, before is even the facing project that that first project on poverty and my connection with Pat and how that that moved me the story, sitting down with her and helping capture that. Tell me about the first time you had a similar experience when you were helping someone else tell their story through the facing project?
00;18;37;25 - 00;18;58;15
Kelsey Timmerman
Timmerman: Yeah. I mean, you know, I kind of came to like the facing project, having done a lot of reporting around the world, whether it's individuals who who left their home in Honduras and hiked across the border to make a better life in the United States, or guy in West Africa who was enslaved on a cacao farm. And through all that.
00;18;58;16 - 00;19;20;20
Kelsey Timmerman
Like, these stories are heavy. And they, they they, you know, like these chains, these necklaces that are each story weighs a little bit. And I've walked away from those stories at times and like later, like, was in tears. But I have never been moved to tears. Like in an interview with someone, in a conversation with someone until facing Project Story.
00;19;20;20 - 00;19;46;10
Kelsey Timmerman
And I think that's something that's really unique about the facing project, because it's not just like you're writing this person's like third person story. You're hearing these words knowing that you're going to have to walk in these words. So it was a a mother who had lost a child. And so she's sharing her story. And then it just comes out that he, like, just unexpectedly passed away at night.
00;19;46;10 - 00;20;10;02
Kelsey Timmerman
And it just out of out of nowhere, I start sobbing. And it was unexpected because I had all these other experiences, like people affected by wars and disease and, and poverty. And I kind of maintained some level of maybe professionalism, if you want to call it that way. I'm still trying to maintain some humanity, but this one, I was like, apologizing.
00;20;10;02 - 00;20;14;19
Kelsey Timmerman
And it wasn't just like a little bit. It was like a full on like like you had to be.
00;20;14;19 - 00;20;17;00
J.R. Jamison
Jamison: Excused, like stand up and walk away.
00;20;17;01 - 00;20;37;20
Kelsey Timmerman
Timmerman: And she like, you know, put her arm around me and said, it's okay. The the tears on her, the journey. Yeah. And I ended up working that into the story. So I think it's just really unique about I mean, that story like she's, you know, just to have that, that empathy, trying to see the world from her point of view and walk in those words.
00;20;37;20 - 00;20;47;01
Kelsey Timmerman
And when you make that pivot to try to do that, like you feel it a little bit more than a typical like story that I was reported on in the past.
00;20;47;02 - 00;21;26;22
J.R. Jamison
Jamison: Yeah. And listening is such an important part of the journey, which seems so simple. But, you know, the work that that we do, I mean, that you started that I became a part of that grew into this bigger thing. We talk about acts of empathy, and that includes listening. Of course, writing is a big part of that. Walking in someone else's shoes, even though you can never really walk in someone else's shoes, but through the written word or the spoken word and active listening, it is possible to begin to understand what it's like for someone else and to understand their lived experience.
00;21;26;27 - 00;21;44;25
J.R. Jamison
And I know in the listening process so often, I find this in conversations with people all the time. I'm sure you do, to where you realize people aren't actually in the moment with you and you can feel, I mean, you can feel when somebody is actually moment.
00;21;44;28 - 00;21;46;07
Kelsey Timmerman
Timmerman: I make it really hard. I can't.
00;21;46;11 - 00;21;48;17
J.R. Jamison
Jamison: I know, and I and I'm not going to blink.
00;21;48;20 - 00;21;51;20
Kelsey Timmerman
Timmerman: To stare down. Now I'm really listening to you really hard.
00;21;51;23 - 00;22;16;29
J.R. Jamison
Jamison: Making you really nervous the more I stare at you. But this idea of having an idea, it's just like somehow it's become part of our culture. And I don't know if this is universal, global or whatever or if this is like clearly an American issue, but people are just waiting for their turn to talk. Yeah. And waiting for their turn to share their thought or idea or their counterargument.
00;22;17;01 - 00;22;34;25
J.R. Jamison
And authentic listening just is kind of out the window. And what we're doing is trying to bring that back in many ways. And part of that is right, encouraging people as they're talking by nodding to show that you're listening, but giving them the space to continue.
00;22;34;26 - 00;22;36;29
Kelsey Timmerman
Timmerman: We're both nodding right now. Yeah. Right.
00;22;37;00 - 00;23;07;25
J.R. Jamison
Jamison: To know that they're not going to be interrupted, just, you know, to to keep that nodding and creating that space, that listening space that leads to empathy. And I think what you were saying around meeting with the storyteller and her sharing this really intimate moment in her life, the death of her child, and that moved you in such a way that had you just been ticking off boxes to get through an interview, would it have?
00;23;07;28 - 00;23;26;17
Kelsey Timmerman
Timmerman: And also, I think it's in person to you, you know, like we when we went through Covid and we couldn't be together and we were trying to do facing projects virtually. I also think that makes it more complex as well. There's some magic that happens when you're next to someone. You're breathing the same air. You can put an arm around someone.
00;23;26;19 - 00;23;46;18
Kelsey Timmerman
Yeah. During Covid, I was reporting a story and I was in a truck with a guy, and we were both, like, masking. And then eventually his mask was kind of came down. He started to shared a story about also losing a child, and I felt like I couldn't actively listen because I had this mask and I couldn't reflect that.
00;23;46;19 - 00;24;06;13
Kelsey Timmerman
I was trying to be empathetic, and I was felt his story. And eventually, like, I pulled down my mask just so I could. I was trying just my eyes, you know? And so I think, like, listening is an active thing and I think so is empathy. I think that's something that we can work at and get more. We get get better at.
00;24;06;13 - 00;24;17;09
Kelsey Timmerman
And so question for you, like do you feel yourself through this work or just just writing and reading? Do you feel yourself becoming more empathetic?
00;24;17;12 - 00;24;30;29
J.R. Jamison
Jamison: I do, in fact. I mean something that our listeners may not know, but every facing project that's ever written, no matter where it is geographically, comes to us. And we read all of those stories.
00;24;31;02 - 00;24;32;10
Kelsey Timmerman
Timmerman: So we come pretty heavy.
00;24;32;14 - 00;25;01;13
J.R. Jamison
Jamison: We read thousands of stories that deal with really heavy issues, and I've been moved to tears before. When I'm reading stories, I have stories that make me angry. Not necessarily the storyteller, but a situations that they experienced in their lives. And I think all of those kinds of narratives do shift my own mindset, get rid of some of my prejudice that maybe I didn't even realize I had.
00;25;01;13 - 00;25;32;07
J.R. Jamison
But there are some stories that I read, and I. I start to feel a little uncomfortable at times. Some of the stories. But there's learning in that uncomfortableness, right? Like if we allow ourselves to lean in, not to use that word that's overused, right? Or that phrase. But if you allow yourself to lean into that comfortable, that's happening when someone's telling you their story or you're reading it, that's the moment in that silence and that uncomfortableness.
00;25;32;07 - 00;25;54;24
J.R. Jamison
If you can just lean in and step back, that allows you to learn. That's that's the moment to learn. And we all have we all have space and capacity to learn more, right? None of us have the answers. And even when we think something is exactly the way that the world is and should be, immediately someone's going to come.
00;25;54;25 - 00;26;20;16
J.R. Jamison
It might be the generation behind us might come with a new idea or a new way of seeing the world, and that makes us uncomfortable. But it's also a time for us to listen and understand why they view the world the way they do, and what we can learn from that. And in turn, how can we begin to empathize with these stories, these new stories, these new ways of, of of being?
00;26;20;17 - 00;26;39;00
J.R. Jamison
And so definitely facing project stories have shifted my worldview, even when I thought I was probably the most open minded person in the world. It's reinforced some stereotypes in many ways that maybe I carried, but also broke many of them down. And we've we've talked about this before.
00;26;39;04 - 00;26;50;11
Kelsey Timmerman
Timmerman: It's like you just empathize with people you agree with. You know what I mean? Like that's the challenge like to have sometimes I think there's a term called radical empathy. And I'll try to apply this to certain situations where.
00;26;50;11 - 00;26;51;26
J.R. Jamison
Jamison: I love that term. But keep talking and.
00;26;51;26 - 00;27;11;08
Kelsey Timmerman
Timmerman: I'll be like, really mad at someone, you know, and then I'll just try to step back. And I think because I've exercised the empathy muscle so much, I was like, all right, I've come across people in stories I disagree with before, but what else? Like their history, what else? There lived experience and and you know, some of that I don't know.
00;27;11;09 - 00;27;33;29
Kelsey Timmerman
And some of you just have to imagine but like to try to have empathy for that person's point of view, even if their view is. It doesn't mean you have to agree with their point of view. I've read plenty of product stories I don't agree with, you know, but it's it's to be able to empathize. Empathy doesn't just just extend to people necessarily that we always agree with.
00;27;34;00 - 00;27;56;16
J.R. Jamison
Jamison: Right? Yeah. Well, because then if we're only talking and listening to people we agree with and we're hearing a story from them that is emotional, like, yeah, we're likely going to be moved, but we're also in kind of an echo chamber, because if we are just only talking to people we agree with at all times, that doesn't get us anywhere as a society, right?
00;27;56;17 - 00;28;01;23
J.R. Jamison
That that just kind of keeps us in this space of the same.
00;28;01;25 - 00;28;27;02
Kelsey Timmerman
Timmerman: And it's possible. It's really possible now, right? Because we can find our online communities. So much of much of us live in an online world. It's in our pocket of people that are just like us. And that has actually empathy isn't always a is a good thing. Like some of the readings I've done on empathy talks about how, you know, empathy is a spotlight and it requires proximity or some familiar familiarity.
00;28;27;02 - 00;28;34;25
J.R. Jamison
Jamison: It's a hard word. I have empathy for you because I have hard words too that I sometimes thank you trip over.
00;28;34;28 - 00;29;01;03
Kelsey Timmerman
Timmerman: But like it. So it requires that proximity and you don't. It's hard to extend that to people outside of that, like spotlight. And I think that's one of the challenges of, of of empathy. Like it can it can be tribalism, it can be nationalism. It can be just people in your religion sudden. It leads to these groups. So empathy doesn't some people's view doesn't always equal a good thing.
00;29;01;09 - 00;29;24;09
Kelsey Timmerman
Now I like to think can it be like panned out. You know, like as you exercise that muscle. And I have empathy for someone who's lived a vastly different experience than I have. The next time I come across someone who's at a vastly different experience I've had in my I able to have, am I able to have more likely to have empathy for that individual as well?
00;29;24;09 - 00;29;43;01
Kelsey Timmerman
And I think that's the that's the hope I have to have. Just empathy just leads to tribalism that we can pan it out and we're all just one big tribe, and not just to humans, but also to the animals and the rest of our biosphere. Like, can we have empathy for a rock? Yeah.
00;29;43;04 - 00;30;08;28
J.R. Jamison
Jamison: Well, I mean, I would hope we're we're all connected, even in animal objects on this planet. We're all connected, right? I mean, we cannot escape our connection to an animal and other species, to the soil, to the grass, to the rocks, to all these things. We're interconnected. If we try to separate ourselves out, that's the end, right? Is that the end of the planet is at the end of.
00;30;09;00 - 00;30;20;24
J.R. Jamison
I mean, we're already seeing in some ways, if people ignore the world around us, that has catastrophic consequences.
00;30;20;27 - 00;30;40;08
Kelsey Timmerman
Timmerman: So one of the places I went on my sabbatical here was I went to Columbia to hang out with this indigenous group called the Arhuaco, and I thought they were going to teach me about, like, sustainable regenerative farming. That's what the book is about. And they're like, well, we're going to go sit here next to this river and we're going to ask permission to farm.
00;30;40;08 - 00;30;58;28
Kelsey Timmerman
We're going to we're going to think about things. And so they would say, all right. Think of a food. And I'm like bacon. You know, he thought. And then like, okay, now what does that food eat or what. Give that what gave that food life. So I'm thinking like oh you know some some corn grew well gave the corn life, son.
00;30;58;29 - 00;31;17;06
Kelsey Timmerman
And all of a sudden I started spiraling down into those like, oh my gosh, everything is connected, you know? And I think that is, if you think about anything, a rock. Well, okay. A rock outside of the stream here in Indiana. Well, 300 million years ago or whatever it was underwater, there were fish swimming by and they got moved.
00;31;17;06 - 00;31;43;04
Kelsey Timmerman
And, you know, this has a history. It had a a life before you come into contact with it, just as every person does. And if we can look at people and we can acknowledge that they have a history and experiences that that we could know if we'd listen to it, or we could at least maybe imagine. And that gives me hope that we could extend that to like everyone.
00;31;43;06 - 00;32;12;21
J.R. Jamison
Jamison: Yeah. And especially social media, which I think, you know, was meant originally to bring us together this idea of a platform that anyone in the world with an internet connection could get on, and you could be connected and you could learn about each other. And it was really exciting in those early days. I mean, I'm sure our listeners are not going to be surprised by any of this because most people are on social media and see that it did the exact opposite.
00;32;12;27 - 00;32;33;13
J.R. Jamison
It's really divided us and put us into these silos. When you were talking about being in the back end of the truck and wearing the mask, I kept thinking about this idea of, you couldn't really connect with that person in that moment because they couldn't see your expressions, your, you know, the kind of the body language on your face.
00;32;33;16 - 00;33;05;06
J.R. Jamison
And that's similar to social media, right? If people spent more time in person having hard conversations and listening to those hard conversations, perhaps we wouldn't have such a divide. But most of us spend our time, our waking hours on the internet and on social media. And there's something about that space where we cannot totally empathize in that moment.
00;33;05;06 - 00;33;29;17
J.R. Jamison
I do think there are ways that you can like, for instance, you know, we'll post facing project stories. There are other storytelling orgs who do great stories as well that they put out there that you could read online, and it does does move you. But when you look at social media overall in the interactions, that lack of face to face body language, it's almost like the mask that you were wearing in that moment.
00;33;29;18 - 00;33;31;24
J.R. Jamison
It's like social media is also.
00;33;31;26 - 00;33;33;02
Kelsey Timmerman
Timmerman: Like way more of a mask, right?
00;33;33;04 - 00;33;41;27
J.R. Jamison
Jamison: Way more of a mask. And how do we how do we break that, break that down? How do we take that mask off? I, I don't know, I don't.
00;33;41;28 - 00;33;58;25
Kelsey Timmerman
Timmerman: Yeah I mean I think it's a trend. I think some of it was here before social media. We were talking earlier about the book Boyne alone. There's that. It was like pre-internet really definitely pre-social media. And that there was there was more people bowling in the United States, but fewer people bowling in leagues, more people bowling by themselves.
00;33;58;25 - 00;34;32;05
Kelsey Timmerman
And so I do think that our culture kind of has this momentum of individualism that, you know, we separated from one another. We don't need our families as much as we used to because we have different social supports or maybe a certain level of economic success. And there's just less community organizations that people are belonging to. And so we seek out in that community other places, which I think what makes the work like the facing project, sitting down with someone in your community, listening to them and then, you know, working with them on that final story is like so important.
00;34;32;07 - 00;34;33;15
Kelsey Timmerman
So I have a question for you.
00;34;33;16 - 00;34;33;27
J.R. Jamison
Jamison: Yes.
00;34;33;27 - 00;34;53;26
Kelsey Timmerman
Timmerman: Yeah. So like empathy is just kind of an exercise and imagination. I mean, you could learn details of someone's story in their history and their experiences. But you're you're trying to see the world from their point of view. Like that's kind of like the best definition of empathy. But you can't I can't be you. I've actually written you've.
00;34;53;26 - 00;34;55;02
J.R. Jamison
Jamison: Written my story before.
00;34;55;04 - 00;35;04;27
Kelsey Timmerman
Timmerman: Yeah. And it's weird, right? Like you're like, I wouldn't exactly written out like that. So it's like, I can't write from even using your words. I can't still put them together in a way that's like.
00;35;04;27 - 00;35;20;02
J.R. Jamison
Jamison: Yeah, but we were forced and that's what we do in facing project. It was like this. You and I were then forced to work together to make it a piece that you were proud of as a writer, and I felt like, sounded like me and conveyed my message as a storyteller. And that's kind of the magic in some ways.
00;35;20;04 - 00;35;21;01
J.R. Jamison
But yeah, you're right.
00;35;21;01 - 00;35;24;26
Kelsey Timmerman
Timmerman: I had to make up some details because your life wasn't interesting enough. That was not true.
00;35;24;27 - 00;35;30;09
J.R. Jamison
Jamison: We we tell all of our writers on facing project not to make anything up. So.
00;35;30;09 - 00;35;55;06
Kelsey Timmerman
Timmerman: But but speaking of making stuff up, you've you've been writing nonfiction and these facing project stories for for decades now and but now you're starting to maybe I'm breaking some news here to write some fiction explorer fiction. So like, yeah, you're switching. So has that taught you anything about empathy as you're made up these characters and you're seeing the world from their point of view?
00;35;55;09 - 00;36;22;18
J.R. Jamison
Jamison: It has. I can't give away too many details of the book I'm working on now for a variety of reasons. I think you understand, but I will share. The main character in my book is a 17 year old with an anxiety disorder, and he's gay, and he was kicked out of his home. And the trajectory of the story then follows his life beyond that.
00;36;22;19 - 00;36;48;07
J.R. Jamison
So I'll give you that much of it. I am a gay man, but I was fortunate that I was never kicked out of my family. Of course, I had the nerves that every gay person has when they need to come out to their family, their loved ones, their friends. But I was fortunate that once I got past that, my family pretty much accepted me.
00;36;48;09 - 00;37;11;17
J.R. Jamison
But in this story that I'm writing, that's not the case. And we've collected so many facing project stories of teenagers, college age students, even some adults who were reflecting back on their teenage years who were thrown out of their homes. They became homeless. They had to figure out at 15, 16, 17 year old, 17 years old, what was next for them in their lives.
00;37;11;17 - 00;37;45;24
J.R. Jamison
And that's a story of tragedy. It's a story that doesn't always have a happy ending, but that's a reality with with stories, right? We are always stuck on this idea of where you should have resolution, but that's not reality. That's not life. And I want to write stories that don't always have resolution. So thinking about stories we've carried before and putting myself into the lived experience of those stories, and in this case of the 17 year old who is a fictional character.
00;37;45;24 - 00;38;11;24
J.R. Jamison
But I had to think back on my own time as a 17 year old. And what would I have done? Had I been thrown out by my parents? And if I also had anxiety as well on top of that, or, you know, other mental health issues? How do you navigate life? So I had to put myself in that mindset to think about what would I do.
00;38;11;24 - 00;38;31;25
J.R. Jamison
And so that's kind of the reactionary piece that you get on the page. And of course, there's just as much research that you have to do with fiction as there is nonfiction. So the research is happening with that to understand disorders and how that compounds and etc., etc. once I put myself in that mindset, it it was challenging.
00;38;31;25 - 00;38;54;28
J.R. Jamison
It put me in a dark place. I mean, there were some scenes in that book writing it. I myself became anxiety ridden and a bit depressed. The difference is I can go on a run to clear my mind, come back home, have a good dinner with my husband, and be good for a few days until I'm ready to jump back into my manuscript.
00;38;55;01 - 00;39;25;27
J.R. Jamison
But I absolutely had to put myself in the shoes of a 17 year old who had come out, was not accepted, was compounded by an anxiety disorder, and had to navigate life without his family and the only place he ever knew as home. And you do begin to empathize. I mean, there are there are numbers and stats connected to teens who are thrown out, who become homeless, who have to end up becoming sex workers to make ends meet.
00;39;25;27 - 00;40;01;25
J.R. Jamison
And that's never been my reality. And while I could read the stories and always think that's awful, I should be doing more as a person who didn't have that experience, it wasn't until I was able to turn to fiction that I could actually put myself in that experience, to write a long form story that I hope, you know, once it's out into the world, can help people, other people who read it understand and empathize with a gay teenager who was kicked out of their home trying to make their way.
00;40;01;25 - 00;40;32;21
J.R. Jamison
So as many of the nonfiction stories that I've read around this that make me, of course, sad and empathize. It wasn't until I actually had to fall into the life of the 17 year old character and make the decisions on the page, right? It's not like I'm capturing something that somebody else experienced, but rather putting myself in that position and then capturing that experience on the page.
00;40;32;24 - 00;40;35;15
J.R. Jamison
It changed me in a different way. You can know.
00;40;35;15 - 00;40;37;01
Kelsey Timmerman
Timmerman: That person's whole story.
00;40;37;02 - 00;40;39;27
J.R. Jamison
Jamison: I know that person's whole story because I am that person.
00;40;40;02 - 00;40;43;21
Kelsey Timmerman
Timmerman: Which is impossible with any other real story. Real person.
00;40;43;22 - 00;41;14;03
J.R. Jamison
Jamison: Yeah. So I'm actually finding like fiction is a good way to create empathy, especially for writers. But I do think also for readers where before I always kind of leaned on the nonfiction to be the place, because those are real stories. You can't argue, well, you can. Some people will write, we we know we live in a society where people argue about anything, but you really can't argue with someone's lived experience, right?
00;41;14;04 - 00;41;41;01
J.R. Jamison
That's their life. They've lived it. And so that's what works so well with nonfiction is like, this is somebody lived experience on the page versus fiction where it's made right. Or it could be inspired by Travis. But my perspective really changed on that once I forced myself to be my character and have to make decisions as I was writing on what do I do for my next meal?
00;41;41;03 - 00;42;02;05
J.R. Jamison
I'm alone on this train track, walking. I'm hungry. I have no skills of hunting or figuring out if a plan time going to eat is poisonous. What do you do in that moment? And as you're writing that story, you got to figure out what you're going.
00;42;02;05 - 00;42;02;21
Kelsey Timmerman
Timmerman: To need to feel.
00;42;02;21 - 00;42;14;16
J.R. Jamison
Jamison: That you got to feel it, and you got to figure it out. So yeah, writing fiction has has changed me. I wouldn't say it has changed me more than nonfiction, but I would say it's pretty equal. Yeah, yeah, yeah.
00;42;14;18 - 00;42;34;23
Kelsey Timmerman
Timmerman: It seems like another way to exercise the empathy muscle. Yeah. You know, whether it's doing a facing project story or taking a photo of someone, I think there's a lot of different exercises out there. And I think that's why I like the work of the facing project is so important. Other arts organizations. Hey, shout out to English majors.
00;42;34;25 - 00;43;00;14
Kelsey Timmerman
It's different ways of exercising that muscle. And I think what our society needs now more than ever is for people to exercise that empathy muscle and to kind of be able to expand how far they're able to extend that empathy to folks and then let that not just guide their connection, but their actions of their lives, not just their compassion, but your actions of what kind of society are we going to work to, to, to build together?
00;43;00;16 - 00;43;02;03
Kelsey Timmerman
Yeah, but I'm looking forward to reading that book.
00;43;02;04 - 00;43;21;16
J.R. Jamison
Jamison: Yeah. Well, yeah. Stay tuned. Well, Mr. Timmerman, I think that is a good note to end on. Don't be a stranger. Will have you back. And who knows, maybe you'll end up co-hosting the show. Yeah, I don't know. We don't want to. We don't want to put any teasers out there that may or may not be true. Hey.
00;43;21;16 - 00;43;24;25
Kelsey Timmerman
Thanks for having me back. Always great to be in the studios with you.
00;43;24;27 - 00;43;32;06
J.R. Jamison
Jamison: All right. Perfect.
00;43;32;09 - 00;43;55;07
J.R. Jamison
Jamison: Special thanks to Big Brothers Big Sisters and Wittenberg University for planning and organizing the facing projects that led to the two stories shared in today's episode. And also huge thanks to my co-founder of The Facing Project, Kelsey Timmerman, for joining me back in the studio just like old times. To listen to past episodes of this program, visit Indiana Public Radio Project.
00;43;55;07 - 00;44;21;20
J.R. Jamison
From there, you can subscribe to the podcast where you'll get episodes of the facing project delivered to your device each month, or just ask your smart speaker to play the facing project on NPR. Listeners can contribute stories or volunteer to share the stories of others that may appear on the show. More information at Facing Project. To continue the conversation about this episode, find us on Facebook, Instagram and Twitter at The Facing Project.
00;44;21;21 - 00;44;46;29
J.R. Jamison
The Facing project is recorded at Indiana Public Radio at Ball State University and Beautiful and Wonderful, Muncie, Indiana, and is produced by the amazing producer and sound engineer extraordinaire, Sean Ashcraft. The show is distributed nationally through. I'm your host, J.R. Jamison. And until next time, I wish you the courage to share your own story and the empathy to listen to others.
00;44;47;01 - 00;45;05;29
Sean Ashcraft
Ashcraft: Support for the facing project comes from Behavior Associates providing intensive therapy, individualized academic instruction, and social skills training for children with autism behavior associates analysts develop an individualized treatment plan for each child receiving services. Presenting sponsor of the facing project. More at behavior ABA.